Myers & Hayden Insurance is a one stop insurance agency
We are your trusted independent insurance agency
What Make Us Special
What Make Us Special
Trusted by 400+ Families
Customer Focus
Customised Coverages
Grange Insurance Awards
Pekin Insurance Awards
ERIE Insurance Awards
About Myers & Hayden Insurance
Many years in business
100% customer satisfaction
Knowledgeable advisors
Multiple coverage options
Myers & Hayden Insurance is a one stop insurance agency.
Since 1988, we’ve helped families and businesses protect what matters most. As an independent agency, we compare trusted carriers to match you with coverage that fits—at a competitive price.
Our Story
Myers & Hayden Insurance was founded by Rick Myers and Don Hayden after their careers at Nationwide. Jill Myers joined as co owner in 2014 and became sole owner in 2020. Today, our Fort Wayne team combines friendly service with deep expertise to guide you with clarity and care.
What Sets Us Apart
- Independent & Local: Options from multiple carriers, not one-size-fits-all.
- Clear Guidance: Straightforward explanations so you can decide with confidence.
- Responsive Service: Same-day help for most requests.
- Strong Partners: Carriers known for great coverage, fair premiums, and reliable claims.
30+ Years of Experience
We have 30+ years of experience, which has helped us earn our client's trust with superior service.
Trusted by 400+ Families
We have helped over 400+ families make educated decisions about their finances
Customer Focus
We are focused on providing the best services possible to meet your needs and demands.
Customised Coverages
We provide customized coverages and insurance that reflect your goals and objectives.
We are your trusted independent insurance agency.
Myers & Hayden have been providing insurance solutions to the Fort Wayne area since 1988. We come with over 80 years of combined experience in the risk management industry and pride ourselves on ensuring you make well-informed decisions. Insurance can be confusing. We try to help our clients understand why they may or may not need a specific type of insurance in their lives.
Our clients have been with us for many years. They’re part of our extended family and their insurance needs change as their lives change. We advise them on the best course to take to protect their own families and their assets. We’re proud to be Hoosiers, living and working in small business. We’re proud to be part of the American dream.
What Make Us Special
- We respond quickly to our clients’ requests.
- We’re small but we manage to get a lot of things done. There are only a few of us in the office so you always know who you’re talking to.
- Many of our staff have been personally affected by those without insurance; therefore, we take extra care to ensure that everyone is covered accurately.
- We’re on the ground and available to speak on your behalf or represent you during the claims process.
- We’re friendly and down-to-earth, with a work ethic that comes from growing up in the Midwest.
- The owners of the agency both work in the business every day, handling everything from quoting risks to servicing policies.
- We’re located in the College Park office park next to IPFW and Ivy Tech.
- We attend several continuing education classes per year to learn about new coverage options and what’s going on in the insurance industry.
Grange Insurance Awards
Pekin Insurance Awards
ERIE Insurance Awards
Our Mission
At Myers & Hayden Insurance Agency, we are dedicated to assisting our clients with their need to protect, save and grow their assets. We create long-term relationships because our customers' needs change over time, and we will be there to meet those changing needs.
